There are two reasons why GA has been adament about not privatizing ATC. The first one is the fees. Janice Wood, in her article, states "The plan, brought up now as part of the reauthorization of the FAA, raises — once again — the spectre of user fees, which GA has been fighting for more than a decade." (Wood, 2015). Additionally, there is a fear, from GA, that privatizing will cause certain air traffic, specifically the airlines, to gain priority.
Many of the airlines are pushing for ATC to be released from FAA control, and turned into a non-profit. Airlines that include, American, Alaska, JetBlue, and Southwest, along with cargo carriers (Atlas, FedEx), "told reporters on a conference call that a corporation with a board of
industry leaders would work faster than FAA to modernize equipment and
adopt more efficient flight paths." (Jansen, 2015)
ATC is, in fact privatized in other countries, and is safe and sufficient. "Commercialized air traffic control organizations in Canada, France,
Germany and the United Kingdom “operate with varying degrees of
government ownership, but each runs like a business,
generating their own revenue streams and making their own decisions
regarding operating the air traffic system and modernizing equipment,”
according to a Department of Transportation inspector general report."
"House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman Bill Shuster
will shortly release draft legislation to convert our nation’s air
traffic control system to a non-profit corporation..." (Robyn, 2015) In '95, the Clinton administration made an attempt to do the same thing, but at the time, very few countries had gone this route. Today, over 60 countries have jumped on board. ATC is now on board as well, knowing that supporting corporatization will secure funding for critical investments.
Truthfully, I can't say one way or the other about whether or not ATC should stay as-is or become privately run. It is an area that, sadly, I have not looked much into, even with numerous friends working in the industry. It seems like two totally different options, but both have the same ultimate goal in mind. Definitely something I will be looking into.
References
Robyn, D. (2015, September 28). It's time to corporatize air traffic
control (the right way). Retrieved from
http://www.brookings.edu/blogs/fixgov/posts/2015/09/28-corporatize-air-traffic-control-robyn
Barton, E. (2015, December 2). Call to action issued over ATC
privatization. Retrieved from
http://dailycaller.com/2015/09/10/transportation-watchdog-lauds-privatized-air-traffic-control/
Jansen, B. (2015, December 2). Call to action issued over ATC privatization. Retrieved December 7, 2015.
Retrieved from http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2015/12/01/airline-executives-urge-privatization-air-traffic-control/76604766/
Wood, J. (2015, July 8). Call to action issued over ATC privatization. Retrieved December 7, 2015.
Retrieved from http://generalaviationnews.com/2015/07/08/call-to-action-issued-over-atc- privatization/
Having privatized ATC doesn't seem like a bad idea. As you said its safe and sufficient in other countries. It would be interesting to see it here.
ReplyDeleteGood work! I found it interesting that certain airlines might gain priority if privatization is enacted. I missed that in my research. Its tough to say how it might turn out if we switch to privatization, but I personally think if the systems not broken then don't fix it.
ReplyDeleteI didn't know that in the 90's there was a push for a reform that didn't take in Congress. With being in the middle with whether to go for private ATC or not, do you believe that it would be a better idea for the government or FAA to develop a sector that could focus on the technological needs, as a private company would do, since as you said the main goal is the same for both sides?
ReplyDeleteI honestly worry that some greedy... person.. would try so hard to make Donald Trump money out of this system and throw safety out the window without some heavy FAA oversight. I have to agree with the GA folks also in that I couldn't afford to fly (not that I can anyway) outside of a job as a pilot if the user fees rose to some crazy rate.
ReplyDelete